Ten Ways “A Force Awakens” is NOT “A New Hope”!



It goes without saying that The Force Awakens was a return to form for Star Wars. It has 95% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and most fans agree that it was a solidly entertaining, wonderfully nostalgic movie. But there are a lot of naysayers too – people who think it’s a total clone ripoff of A New Hope. I couldn’t disagree more, and I have ten points as to why:

1. Finn

Finn is the most original new character. While Rey harkens back to Luke Skywalker’s origins, and Poe is a snarky foil to Han Solo, we have never been inside the head of a storm trooper.  Watching Finn during his first battle, shell-shocked and disturbed by his comrades dying around him, was moving. Through Finn, we get a better perspective of who storm troopers are, what they go through to become obedient soldiers, where they come from, etc. It added a layer of humanism beneath the helmet, and a protagonist from “the other side” who was wholly original to The Force Awakens.

2. Realistic Violence

When a fallen storm trooper smeared a handprint of blood across Finn’s helmet, I realized it was the first time I’d seen blood in a Star Wars movie. Star Wars violence has always been bloodless and cauterized. But that scene, and when Kylo Ren bleeds from his blaster wound all over the snow, raised the stakes of the Star Wars universe for me.

And then were are the battles. I liked the fight choreography in the prequels, but many people complained that it was “dance-like”. I’ll admit, the prequel battles were too choreographed and practiced. On the other end, lightsaber fights in the original trilogy were understated and somewhat idle. But between the choreography in The Force Awakens and the sound/VFX design of the lightsabers, I actually felt danger during the vicious duels between Kylo Ren and Rey/Finn. You could almost feel the heat off the swords. You could feel that the characters were fighting for their lives. Let’s be real – Obi-Wan may say that a lightsaber is an elegant weapon, but it’s a sword made of plasma. So I loved how Kylo and Rey were soaked with sweat and beaten/burned by the end of their fight. It’s a more realistic representation of what a that sort of fight would look like.

3. Entirely Different Dynamic Between The Bad Guys and The Good

In A New Hope, the Empire was the galactic government. It was reasonable to assume that the Empire funded the Death Star through taxes, had the means to create a galactic military, and were able to keep their iron grip on the universe because they were judge, jury, and executioner.

Not so is the dynamic between the New Republic and The First Order. Unfortunately, the film glosses over how the Republic actually functions, how the Resistance serves them, and how far the Republic reaches. But from what we gather, The First Order operates more like the rebels in this film, bombarding a government they believe is unjust.

It is still unclear how they get their funding and resources, but I found The First Order to be a timely analogy to fringe organizations like ISIS which can fester and grow in a volatile, vacuum of power. They are not an empire so much as a terrorist group. While the original six movies may have showed us the Fall of Rome, these new movies seem to echo a more modern political climate.

4. Diversity

It was fabulous seeing an excellently acted, non-sexualized female character as an exceptional pilot and future Jedi. And while this film was super feminist, it took the Mad Max route of understated feminism. Rey never needs saving – but this is never a big deal. It never seems like the writers are asking for a golden star for creating a capable woman.  Finn and Han are also wonderful male allies, who do not argue with her agency or her abilities.

And of course, John Boyega’s Finn adds a well-rounded black character to the galaxy who isn’t a 70’s Blaxploitation cliché (sorry Lando…love you, but it’s true). Leia abandoned her Princess title in favor of General. The imposing Captain Phasma was a woman, although sorely underused. There were other female stormtroopers throughout and plenty of women at the rebel base and in X-Wings (including women of color with speaking roles). And again, none of this seemed like the producers were trying too hard.

5. A Capable Imperial Army

While The First Order may be a fringe group, they seemed to recognize what made the original Empire flawed. Gone are stormtroopers who are useless, disposable, and terrible at shooting. The 501st actually has characters to be proud of here. General Hux is the most wonderfully insane disciplinarian. Multiple Force users are present in the Knights of Ren, not just one Sith leader. And that anti-lightsaber electric blade that a stormtrooper used to fight Finn? Awesome. Seeing as their last Empire was destroyed by Jedi, it makes sense that The First Order would prepare themselves to fight lightsabers and other Force users this time around.

6. An Unbalanced Force…and No Sith

Without getting into too much detail about what the Force being “in balance” means, it was very clear that Kylo Ren and Rey both have crazy amounts of power flowing through them. I found this really interesting, because it perhaps implies that the Force’s balance has less to do with the scales of good and evil, and more to do with the dispersion of it’s power amongst a number of people. If you only have a couple of Force users, do they “hog” the Force? Even more head-scratching is the fact that Kylo Ren is not a Sith – he is a dark Force user of a different order. We’ve always been told that there must be two Sith to keep balance to the Force, so I wonder if a lack of Sith has thrown off the cosmos. Certainly none of these questions arose in A New Hope, and none of the Force users were nearly this powerful. And I suspect that continual analysis of this “balance” will be a key plot arc throughout the entire trilogy.

7. An X-Wing Fight in the Middle, and a Lightsaber Fight at the End

Getting into some more specific plot beats, a side-by-side analysis proves that The Force Awakens does not really resemble A New Hope. In A New Hope, our middle act is primarily occupied by Luke, Han, Chewie, and Obi-Wan heading to the Death Star on a rescue mission to save Princess Leia. The middle act of A Force Awakens doesn’t really resemble a rescue mission at all – unless you count Finn and Han going to save Rey, but not actually needing to. Instead, our new second act primarily concerns the heroes trying to return BB-8 to his home base so the Resistance can locate Luke Skywalker.

If The Force Awakens did use the same plot, what we would have seen is Rey encountering Luke Skywalker on Jakku, leaving with him to rescue Poe Dameron from the First Order based on BB-8’s intel, Luke dying at the hands of Kylo Ren during the rescue mission, and then Poe/Rey destroying the Star Killer Base with X-Wings. Finn wouldn’t be there, Luke would have had a presence as a mentor Jedi, and we wouldn’t have seen the Resistance til the last 30 minutes. Luke and Vader did not have a lightsaber fight at the climax of A New Hope….but Kylo Ren and Rey/Finn did. The Rebels did not swoop in to help the heroes save Leia from the Death Star…but the Resistance helped the heroes escape from Maz Kanata’s planet.

Of course, there were some similarities, such as the Star Killer Base  destroying planets a la the Death Star blowing up Alderaan. But every similarity was either remixed in some way or shown to us as a mirror of what originally happened. Such as…







8. The Son Killing the Father

One may immediately draw similarity between Kylo Ren killing Han Solo to Vader killing Obi-Wan in A New Hope. You even had Rey screaming “No!” from afar as Luke did when he saw his mentor cut down. However, I found that scene far more reminiscent of the Empire Strikes Back Cloud City scene between Vader and Luke. Vader, his hand outstretched to his son, with a hope that his son will join him. And Luke, rejecting his father, and choosing to fall to his assumed death rather than to darkness.

Han, a good man, tries to bring his dark son home, mirroring a dark father trying to bring his light son to evil. Both Luke and Kylo Ren choose death over joining their fathers…except Luke selflessly chooses death for himself, and Kylo Ren kills his father because Han is an obstacle. This is the type of “rhyming” I hoped JJ Abrams would go for in The Force Awakens. Poignant, similar, but different.

9. Emotion

One thing always baffled me about Star Wars: a lack of emotional depth. For a franchise so famous, you would think Lucas wove in heart-wrenching stuff that girls on Tumblr cry over and write fanfiction about. But rarely has Star War prompted me to cry “My Feels!” It has action and humor and likeable characters and myth. And in many ways, good writing. But between the hammy dialogue and the wooden acting that has plagued all six prior movies, I seldom felt emotionally moved.

I’m glad to say that The Force Awakens perfects the recipe. The actors are strong, the dialogue was more realistic, the writing hit good emotional beats, and there’s a sense that JJ Abrams actually directed his actors. George Lucas is a visionary and a good storyteller, but I don’t think he ever tried to pull good performances out of his actors. Whatever the reason, The Force Awakens has a beating heart that appealed to my inner fangirl on a level greater than just nostalgia.

10. Shades of Grey

There is not much of a middle ground in A New Hope. You’re either good or bad. Han Solo is the closest thing we get to morally grey, but he’s obviously still a good person at heart. We never doubt for a moment that he is a hero.

But The Force Awakens deals with a storm trooper turned Resistance fighter who has been on both sides of the war. Kylo Ren is torn between the light and the dark. Rey has a wild amount of power that she cannot control, as well as anger towards the family who abandoned her. And in a universe where The First Order are now the rebellion, perhaps we have to question if the Republic is actually a good system. We now operate in a gray area instead of black and white. And I have to give some credit to the prequels here, because the story of Anakin Skywalker was the original kernel for questionable morality on the part of the Jedi, and Separatists like Nute Gunray were almost on the right side of history.

While The Force Awakens certainly holds a mirror to A New Hope, and reflects its elements in opposite ways, it stands alone as its own film and does not hit almost any of the same beats. And even though the movie was indeed self-referential, I think it achieved at its primary goal: regaining trust of the audience. So here’s to Episode 8, which will surely be a more daring and surprising film built on the wonderful foundation that JJ Abrams and Disney-Lucasfilm have laid.

16 thoughts on “Ten Ways “A Force Awakens” is NOT “A New Hope”!

    • True, although I buy blood coming from a blaster wound more than I would buy it coming from a lightsaber wound (and I think all lightsaber wounds inflicted were still bloodless). Perhaps laser blasts are not strong enough to fully cauterize? Perhaps it depends on the blaster? I have no idea – that is minutia that I don’t really touch, lol.

      Even if it is a bit of a plot hole, I still like the stakes it emphasized. The movie was pretty light and humorous. Just that little touch added just enough darkness for me to feel like the bad guys were actually dangerous. Although it will be interesting if bloody blaster wounds becomes a much recited complaint a la “Han Shot First!” over the next few years ^_^

  1. I agree with everything Michelle has said!
    I can see why folks might think it is a re-hash on the surface. Star Wars followed the Hero’s Journey, a story method that has been done time and time again. So does this movie. You have a reluctant Hero who has been called to action. They refuse several time but eventually choose to take the call. Along the way they have a spiritual guide or mentor. It could be argued whose journey is it? Rey or Fin or Kylo? I do think the three main characters really are quite different that the original three. Sure there are aspects you can see like Po is very much like Leia. Mature, very loyal to the Resistance. Rey had qualities of Han. The loner, not really wanting to get involved. Happy to stay put where she is. Fin has some of Luke’s traits. Kylo Ren- he’s a bit like Anakin. Kind a whiny kid. Can’t control his anger and has temper tantrums. Not a strong villain but I think he will become one. But then again he may be redeemed. It’s pretty clear that there are many dark jedi’s around so it gives room for stronger villains to emerge if he doesn’t fall in line. My only real disappointment was we really didn’t know the back story of Han and Leia. Did they get married/divorced? How long were they apart? Why would their son turning to the dark side break them up? They had a great love story and it was very sad to see them apart. Their passion for each other was gone. What really happen that would drive Luke into hiding? Perhaps that back story will be in a book.

    • It was entertaining but it was a rip-off of the earlier movies. The plot was a thinly vielled replay of A New Hope. Rebel leader inserts hologram in droid. Then leader gets captured while droid roams desert planet in search of help. Young orphan finds droid takes droid along with Jar Jar aka Fin to cantina where they meet Han solo. Takes millennium falcon to rebel camp. Where they attack death planet. The crew is captured. THey throw guard in garbage bin. Han Solo wanted by Jaba type hunters. Jabba get eaten by aliens while Han escapes. Death Star blows up. Obi Wan fights Darth Vader while the crew watch. He is killed they flee.

      I would much rather have seen the new characters develop on their own. Ray is a strong character. More emphasis should have been placed on the development of her character. Evidently the force is strong in this one so this should have been played up more about her discovery of her abilities.

    • I don’t know if Han and Leia were married but they must have had out of this world sex. I like to know what did they do to their kid to make him turn to the dark side? Why does he hate his parents so much?

  2. I did like the part though when Han Solo stood outside of the millennium falcon, while holding on to his walker while shaking his fist at the clones while saying “Keep off of my ship you young whippersnappers”.

  3. Changing the order of all the re-hashed pieces of ANH does not make it a “different” film. Almost scene-by-scene I could tell you where it was ripped off from.

    • Were there recycled plot elements? Sure. But having seen it a second time today only solidified my opinion that TFA stands on its own in character, design, and in overall “feel”. Any similarities were used to make the audience feel like it’s actually a Star Wars movie – instead of the needless video game lite action sequences and boring sitting-and-talking that the prequels reeked.

      They made movies that were obscenely different from the originals – everyone hated them. So I don’t blame TFA for being a bit of a handshake movie. If Ep8 and 9 are as derivative I might whine, but I think people need to really sit down and ponder what exactly they wanted TFA to BE. What would have actually pleased people? I’m starting to think nothing will.

  4. History tends to repeat itself so why wouldn’t it in a movie. Plus those classic mythological archetypes and stories have been told for 1000’s of years. I think many people wanted it to follow the EU as those were good stories. However they didn’t choose to go that way. We need to get over it. You really need to table your expectations and just see the movie as a movie, not to compare it to anything. It’s a good movie period.


      Tbh I love the seeds they’ve planted in TFA so much that I’m actually….thinking up an Episode 8 fanfic. I so do not have time to write it, but my brain is working on it, that’s for sure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s